SaneCite

Terms and limits

What our results are, what they cover, and what you may do with them. This page applies to every page on the site.

Who did the reading

AI models read the citations and made the readings on this site, unless a page says people checked them. Each citation in the census was read by three models, and the majority decided. On a blind sample of 150 citing papers, the three models matched a separate AI reader on 142 (94.7%). A check of a random sample by trained human readers is designed and registered, and has not run yet. When it runs we publish the result here, whatever it shows. Every model, score and setting is on the Methods page.

What a flag means

A flag records that a paper cites a work that is retracted, or carries an expression of concern, in the Retraction Watch database. It says nothing about what the citing authors knew or intended, and it does not mean their paper is wrong. Many retractions come after the citing paper was published, and journals rarely tell the authors. A citation error is never called fraud.

What the numbers cover

Counts of citations come from the Retraction Watch database, published by Crossref, and from OpenAlex. Readings cover citations in open-access papers to PubMed-indexed papers retracted from 1990 to 2023: about 43% of all later citations. Counts of the later papers, reviews, trials and grants that cite a retracted paper measure how far it travelled. They do not measure harm. Each chart and report gives its own method: start at the census method.

Checks of numbers and conclusions

When we check a paper’s calculations or conclusions, the rules, the AI prompts and every verdict are published with the result. We send the authors our findings before we publish and print what they reply. A method that differs from common practice does not by itself change a result: where we say a number changes, we show the calculation.

The checker

The checker compares a reference list with the Retraction Watch database, which we refresh every working day. It checks references that have a DOI or a PubMed ID. Read the retraction notice before you rely on a flag. A pasted reference list stays in your browser: only the DOIs and PubMed IDs found in it are sent. Nothing on this site is medical, legal or professional advice.

If we name you

We write to authors and journals before we name them, and print their replies beside their entries. To correct an entry, ask what we hold about you, or object, write to letters@sanecite.com. The full notice is at Lists: your data and About.

Corrections

We date every correction and make it in public: the full list. Found an error? Write to letters@sanecite.com.

Licenses

Our code is under the MIT license and the data we made is under CC BY 4.0: use either for anything, with credit to SaneCite (sanecite.com). Charts are free to share with the same credit. Passages quoted from other authors’ papers stay under those papers’ own licenses.

No warranty

The site, the checker and the data are provided as they are, without warranty of any kind. Check the source before you act on a result.