{
 "_note": "Reach after the retraction, from Europe PMC records read on 29 Oct 2026 for every paper the census found citing the retracted paper as support (label substantive). kinds: Europe PMC publication types. cited_in_turn: every later citation of those papers, not only for this claim. third_order: distinct later papers citing any of those papers (Europe PMC CITES search), with the systematic reviews or meta-analyses, trials and guidelines among them. registered_trials: ClinicalTrials.gov records first submitted after the retraction that list the retracted paper (census sweep). all: the same counts for every listed paper together, each citing paper counted once. chain: one supporting paper followed by reading (chain3.py): later papers that cite it and mention the topic, how many we could read, how many cite it in a sentence on the topic, and how many of those repeat the retracted claim. funded: papers that acknowledge at least one grant; funders: grant agencies as the papers list them, US NIH institutes merged. Reach is not proof of harm.",
 "read": "2026-10-29",
 "papers": {
  "15604363": {
   "support_citers": 104,
   "citers_sha": "c5f53ef0fcca8bf3",
   "kinds": {
    "other": 56,
    "review": 44,
    "systematic review or meta-analysis": 2,
    "trial": 2
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 4426,
    "systematic_reviews": 141,
    "trials": 116,
    "guidelines": 1,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 104
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 0,
    "enrollment": 0,
    "ncts": []
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 4657,
   "funded": 34,
   "funders_n": 49,
   "funders": {
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 6,
    "National Science Centre, Poland": 4,
    "Instituto de Salud Carlos III": 3,
    "US National Institutes of Health": 3,
    "Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca": 2,
    "American Heart Association": 1,
    "British Heart Foundation": 1,
    "Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung": 1,
    "CONACyT-México": 1,
    "CSRD VA": 1,
    "Catholic Medical Center Research Foundation": 1,
    "Deputyship for Research and Innovation, Ministry of Education in Saudi Arabia": 1,
    "Else Kröner-Fresenius-Stiftung": 1,
    "European Union FEDER": 1,
    "Excellent Key Teachers in the “Qing Lan Project” of Jiangsu Colleges and Universities 2019": 1,
    "FEDER": 1,
    "Fondazione AIRC per la ricerca sul cancro ETS": 1,
    "Fondo de Investigaciones Sanitarias": 1,
    "Fondo de Investigación Sanitaria": 1,
    "Gilead Foundation": 1,
    "Guangzhou Municipal Science and Technology Bureau": 1,
    "Guangzhou Science and Technology Program Key Projects": 1,
    "H2020 Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions": 1,
    "Innovation Research Project of the Eye Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University": 1,
    "Japan Society for the Promotion of Science": 1,
    "Key Science and Technology Research Project of Henan Province": 1,
    "Korea Health Industry Development Institute": 1,
    "Ministero dell'Istruzione, dell'Università e della Ricerca": 1,
    "Ministerstvo Zdravotnictví Ceské Republiky": 1,
    "Ministry of Education and Science": 1,
    "Ministry of Science and Higher Education": 1,
    "Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities": 1,
    "Mutua Madrileña Fundation": 1,
    "NSFC-Henan joint grant": 1,
    "National Children's Research Centre": 1,
    "National Institute for Health Research (NIHR)": 1,
    "National Key R&D Program of China": 1,
    "National Science Council": 1,
    "Natural Science Foundation of Hebei Province": 1,
    "Nutricia Research Foundation": 1,
    "Program for Innovation Research Team of Ministry of Education": 1,
    "RETICS": 1,
    "Shin Kong Wu Ho-Su Memorial Hospital": 1,
    "Spanish Ministry of Health": 1,
    "Telethon": 1,
    "Undergraduate Research and Innovation Plan Project of Nantong University": 1,
    "Universidad de Guadalajara": 1,
    "University of South Carolina University Libraries": 1,
    "«Development of a differentiated approach to management of patients of reproductive age with different forms of endometriosis»": 1
   },
   "chain": {
    "supporting_pmid": "24733068",
    "supporting_year": "2014",
    "supporting_cited_by": 1301,
    "topic": "visfatin",
    "later_mentioning": 67,
    "open_read": 56,
    "cite_it_on_topic": 7,
    "repeat_claim": 0
   }
  },
  "15833829": {
   "support_citers": 26,
   "citers_sha": "41a476bb6a82ae12",
   "kinds": {
    "review": 14,
    "other": 11,
    "trial": 1
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 1509,
    "systematic_reviews": 26,
    "trials": 9,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 26
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 2,
    "enrollment": 90,
    "ncts": [
     "NCT01686139",
     "NCT06163833"
    ]
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 1518,
   "funded": 9,
   "funders_n": 15,
   "funders": {
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 3,
    "US National Institutes of Health": 2,
    "333 Project Talent Foundation of China": 1,
    "China Shenzhen City Science and Technology Bureau": 1,
    "Hong Kong Government Research Grant Council": 1,
    "Japan Society for the Promotion of Science": 1,
    "Key Talent Foundation of China": 1,
    "Lui Che Woo Foundation Limited": 1,
    "Lui Che Woo Institute of Innovative Medicine": 1,
    "Narodowe Centrum Badań i Rozwoju": 1,
    "National Science Centre, Poland": 1,
    "SMART program": 1,
    "The Chinese University of Hong Kong": 1,
    "a Challenging Research (Exploratory) from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan": 1,
    "a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B) from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan": 1
   }
  },
  "17715156": {
   "support_citers": 51,
   "citers_sha": "c75c945a999d3590",
   "kinds": {
    "review": 19,
    "other": 32
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 2003,
    "systematic_reviews": 31,
    "trials": 10,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 51
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 0,
    "enrollment": 0,
    "ncts": []
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 2078,
   "funded": 15,
   "funders_n": 44,
   "funders": {
    "US National Institutes of Health": 6,
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 3,
    "British Heart Foundation": 2,
    "Medical Research Council": 2,
    "AFM-Téléthon": 1,
    "Austrian Center of Industrial Biotechnology, ACIB": 1,
    "Austrian Centre of Biopharmaceutical Technology": 1,
    "Austrian Research Centre Seibersdorf": 1,
    "Austrian Science Fund FWF": 1,
    "BLRD VA": 1,
    "BOKU DOC": 1,
    "Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education": 1,
    "Baxter AG": 1,
    "Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council": 1,
    "Biotop": 1,
    "China Postdoctoral Science Foundation": 1,
    "FIRB": 1,
    "Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities": 1,
    "G. d'Annunzio University": 1,
    "GuangXi Natural Science Foundation": 1,
    "Hallym University Research Fund": 1,
    "Harbin Medical University": 1,
    "Harbin Medical University (HMU)": 1,
    "Jiangsu clinical research center for cardiovascular surgery": 1,
    "Ministero della Salute": 1,
    "NIDDK/NIH": 1,
    "National Clinical Key Specialty of cardiovascular surgery": 1,
    "National Eye Institute": 1,
    "National Natural Science Foundation (NSFC) of China": 1,
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China (National Science Foundation of China)": 1,
    "Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province": 1,
    "Natural Science Foundation of Shandong Province": 1,
    "Natural Science Foundation of Shandong Province (Shandong Provincial Natural Science Foundation)": 1,
    "Natural Science Fund for Colleges and Universities in Jiangsu Province": 1,
    "Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council": 1,
    "PRIN": 1,
    "Qingdao Natural Science Foundation": 1,
    "Science Foundation Ireland": 1,
    "Science and Technology Department of Sichuan Province": 1,
    "Sichuan Academy of Medical Sciences and Sichuan Provincial People’s Hospital": 1,
    "Suzhou Municipal Science and Technology Foundation": 1,
    "Taishan Scholar Foundation of Shandong Province": 1,
    "Vienna Science and Technology Fund (WWTF)": 1,
    "Wellcome Trust": 1
   }
  },
  "18453793": {
   "support_citers": 56,
   "citers_sha": "74f983809965f504",
   "kinds": {
    "other": 46,
    "trial": 7,
    "systematic review or meta-analysis": 1,
    "review": 2
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 225,
    "systematic_reviews": 16,
    "trials": 7,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 56
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 3,
    "enrollment": 1230,
    "ncts": [
     "NCT06068309",
     "NCT06117722",
     "NCT07145983"
    ]
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 195,
   "funded": 18,
   "funders_n": 36,
   "funders": {
    "US National Institutes of Health": 2,
    "2022 CALHN ALLIED HEALTH, PHARMACY & NURSING GRANT": 1,
    "Agenzia Italiana del Farmaco, Ministero della Salute": 1,
    "Beijing Aili Myasthenia Gravis Care Center": 1,
    "Blood disease Clinical medical Center": 1,
    "Boston Scientific": 1,
    "ERC": 1,
    "European Research Council": 1,
    "First People's Hospital of Yunnan Province": 1,
    "Hawassa University": 1,
    "Health Bureau": 1,
    "Health and Medical Research Fund": 1,
    "Horizon 2020": 1,
    "Kollegium für Hausarztmedizin, Switzerland": 1,
    "Medical Research Future Fund (MRFF)": 1,
    "NHMRC": 1,
    "National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases": 1,
    "National Kidney Foundation Singapore": 1,
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 1,
    "North South University": 1,
    "Norwegian University of Science and Technology": 1,
    "Physical Education Department of the University Center, Dr. Leão Sampaio": 1,
    "Rapid Applied Research Translation (RART)": 1,
    "Swiss National Science Foundation": 1,
    "Swiss State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation": 1,
    "Ten Thousand Person Program": 1,
    "This research was supported by the Institute of Research and Community Service from the University of Jember": 1,
    "University of Bern": 1,
    "University of South Australia": 1,
    "ViiV Healthcare": 1,
    "Xuzhou science and technology project": 1,
    "Yunnan Applied Basic Research Projects-Union Foundation": 1,
    "Yunnan Province-The Special Project for Renowned Physicians": 1,
    "Yunnan Provincial Department of Science and Technology and Kunming Medical-University": 1,
    "the Science and technology development fund of Affiliated Hospital of Xuzhou Medical University": 1,
    "the clinical research fund of West China Second University Hospital": 1
   }
  },
  "19918075": {
   "support_citers": 31,
   "citers_sha": "e56b82153b16000d",
   "kinds": {
    "review": 15,
    "other": 14,
    "trial": 1,
    "systematic review or meta-analysis": 1
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 1287,
    "systematic_reviews": 45,
    "trials": 36,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 31
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 0,
    "enrollment": 0,
    "ncts": []
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 1292,
   "funded": 14,
   "funders_n": 21,
   "funders": {
    "Japan Society for the Promotion of Science": 3,
    "US National Institutes of Health": 3,
    "AIRC Programma di ricerca 5 per Mille 2019": 1,
    "Associazione Italiana per la Ricerca sul Cancro": 1,
    "Bando Ricerca Scientifica di Eccellenza 2017 della Fondazione Cassa di Risparmio di Padova e Rovigo": 1,
    "Bando Ricerca Scientifica di Eccellenza 2018 della Fondazione Cassa di Risparmio di Padova e Rovigo": 1,
    "Dept. of Biomedical Sciences, University of Padova": 1,
    "Dept. of Biomedical sciences, UNIPD": 1,
    "Institute for Basic Science": 1,
    "JSPS KAKENHI": 1,
    "Japanese Council for Science, Technology and Innovation": 1,
    "MIUR PRIN 2020": 1,
    "National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke": 1,
    "National Key Research and Development Program of China": 1,
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 1,
    "National Research Foundation of Korea": 1,
    "National Science Centre, Poland": 1,
    "Progetto ricerca sanitaria finalizzata Rep. 100/2019": 1,
    "System for Poultry Production Technology, Beijing Agriculture Innovation Consortium": 1,
    "Takeda Research Support": 1,
    "University of Sharjah": 1
   }
  },
  "21753854": {
   "support_citers": 25,
   "citers_sha": "c9de4312233e2bd6",
   "kinds": {
    "review": 7,
    "other": 18
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 542,
    "systematic_reviews": 7,
    "trials": 2,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 25
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 0,
    "enrollment": 0,
    "ncts": []
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 561,
   "funded": 15,
   "funders_n": 20,
   "funders": {
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 6,
    "US National Institutes of Health": 2,
    "Animal Cancer Foundation": 1,
    "Brooke's Blossoming Hope for Childhood Cancer Foundation": 1,
    "Cancer Institute NSW": 1,
    "Cancer Research UK": 1,
    "China Scholarship Council": 1,
    "Education Department of Sichuan Province": 1,
    "H2020 Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions": 1,
    "Hope Funds for Cancer Research": 1,
    "Ministerium für Wissenschaft, Forschung und Kunst Baden-Württemberg": 1,
    "National Cancer Institute": 1,
    "National Council for Scientific and Technological Development": 1,
    "National Key Technology Support Program": 1,
    "Oregon State University College of Veterinary Medicine": 1,
    "Russian Foundation for Basic Research": 1,
    "Science and Technology development plan of Taicang in jiangsu Province P.R.C.": 1,
    "São Paulo Research Foundation": 1,
    "University of New South Wales": 1,
    "national natural science foundation of china": 1
   }
  },
  "28368401": {
   "support_citers": 30,
   "citers_sha": "581aa454bdc19d06",
   "kinds": {
    "other": 24,
    "review": 6
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 519,
    "systematic_reviews": 4,
    "trials": 0,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 30
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 0,
    "enrollment": 0,
    "ncts": []
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 526,
   "funded": 13,
   "funders_n": 15,
   "funders": {
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 6,
    "Bureau of Science and Technology of Jingzhou Municipality": 1,
    "China Postdoctoral Science Foundation": 1,
    "Deputyship for Research and Innovation, Ministry of Education in Saudi Arabia": 1,
    "Graduate Research and Innovation Projects of Jiangsu Province": 1,
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China (National Science Foundation of China)": 1,
    "Natural Science Foundation of Hubei Province": 1,
    "Nature Science Foundation of Shaanxi Province": 1,
    "Priority Academic Program Development of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions": 1,
    "Scientific Research Project of Health Commission of Shanxi Province": 1,
    "Shaanxi Science and Technology Innovation Project Plan": 1,
    "ShanXi Science and Technology DepartmentS": 1,
    "The Ningbo Natural Science Foundation of China": 1,
    "Tianjin Municipal Bureau of Public Health": 1,
    "no funding associated with the work featured in this article": 1
   }
  },
  "30193239": {
   "support_citers": 53,
   "citers_sha": "4b1e736533f76c69",
   "kinds": {
    "other": 45,
    "trial": 1,
    "review": 6,
    "systematic review or meta-analysis": 1
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 499,
    "systematic_reviews": 32,
    "trials": 10,
    "guidelines": 0,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 53
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 3,
    "enrollment": 349,
    "ncts": [
     "NCT04531774",
     "NCT07220421",
     "NCT07459868"
    ]
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 472,
   "funded": 15,
   "funders_n": 21,
   "funders": {
    "US Department of Veterans Affairs": 2,
    "US National Institutes of Health": 2,
    "Chinese Nursing Association Research Project": 1,
    "DST- NRF Centre of Excellence in Human Development": 1,
    "Guangxi Graduate Education Innovation Project": 1,
    "King Abdullah International Medical Research Center": 1,
    "Korean Neurosurgical Society": 1,
    "Medical Research Council": 1,
    "Mölnlycke": 1,
    "National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences": 1,
    "National Center for Research Resources": 1,
    "National Natural Science Foundation of China": 1,
    "Natural Science Foundation of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region": 1,
    "Novo Nordisk Fonden": 1,
    "Pain Foundation LTD": 1,
    "South African Medical Research Council": 1,
    "United Arab Emirates University": 1,
    "University of Rochester Medical Center": 1,
    "University of Sydney": 1,
    "VHA Office of Primary Care": 1,
    "Vietnam National Foundation for Science and Technology Development": 1
   }
  },
  "32356626": {
   "support_citers": 80,
   "citers_sha": "f488e254c5d68863",
   "kinds": {
    "other": 46,
    "review": 26,
    "systematic review or meta-analysis": 8
   },
   "third_order": {
    "citing_papers": 2461,
    "systematic_reviews": 116,
    "trials": 22,
    "guidelines": 5,
    "supporting_papers_searched": 80
   },
   "registered_trials": {
    "n": 0,
    "enrollment": 0,
    "ncts": []
   },
   "cited_in_turn": 2569,
   "funded": 23,
   "funders_n": 45,
   "funders": {
    "National Institute for Health Research (NIHR)": 3,
    "US National Institutes of Health": 2,
    "ACE": 1,
    "AHRQ HHS": 1,
    "ATHENA Institute of Biomedical Sciences and EnergonBio Technologies S.A., Greece": 1,
    "ATHENA Institute of Biomedical Sciences; EnergonBio Technologies S.A., Greece": 1,
    "Academic Clinical Lecturer": 1,
    "Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality": 1,
    "AstraZeneca": 1,
    "Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation": 1,
    "Bill and Melinda Gates Institute for Population and Reproductive Health": 1,
    "Boehringer Ingelheim": 1,
    "British Heart Foundation": 1,
    "British Journal of Anaesthesia": 1,
    "CSRD VA": 1,
    "Cancer Research UK": 1,
    "Cancer Research UK Oxford Centre": 1,
    "Chiesi Farmaceutici": 1,
    "Fonds Léon Fredericq": 1,
    "Foundation for Scientific and Technological Development in Health": 1,
    "GlaxoSmithKline Australia": 1,
    "Ilam University of Medical Sciences": 1,
    "MRC Epidemiology Unit programme": 1,
    "Medical Research Council": 1,
    "Medizinische Fakultät, RWTH Aachen University": 1,
    "Ministero dell'Istruzione, dell'Università e della Ricerca": 1,
    "Ministry of Education – Kingdom of Saudi Arabi": 1,
    "NHS": 1,
    "National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering": 1,
    "National Key R&D Program of China": 1,
    "Novartis": 1,
    "Public Health England": 1,
    "Qatar Foundation": 1,
    "Research Centre for Gas Innovation": 1,
    "Roche": 1,
    "Russian Science Foundation": 1,
    "Society of Critical Care Medicine": 1,
    "Strong": 1,
    "Swedish Research Council": 1,
    "Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Welfare": 1,
    "Takeda Canada": 1,
    "Umm Al-Qura University": 1,
    "nantong science and technology bureau": 1,
    "the Medical Science and Technology Project of Zhejiang Province,China": 1,
    "the Natural Science Foundation of Zhejiang Province, China": 1
   }
  }
 },
 "all": {
  "support_citers": 456,
  "kinds": {
   "other": 292,
   "review": 139,
   "trial": 12,
   "systematic review or meta-analysis": 13
  },
  "funded": 156,
  "third_order": {
   "citing_papers": 13440,
   "systematic_reviews": 418,
   "trials": 212,
   "guidelines": 6,
   "supporting_papers_searched": 456
  }
 }
}